Comparison · Two North American snapping turtles

Alligator snapping turtle vs common snapping turtle

Quick answer

Look at the shell and the tail. The alligator snapping turtle has three tall, spiky ridges running down its shell, a huge hooked beak and a tail covered in smooth, round bumps. The common snapping turtle has a lower, smoother shell, eyes you can see from above, and a row of large sawtooth scales along the top of its tail. Alligator snappers are also far bigger and live mainly in southern rivers.

Alligator snapping turtle with three rows of tall spiked ridges on its dark shell and a massive hooked beak
Alligator snapping turtle
Macrochelys temminckii
Common snapping turtle on a muddy bank, showing its rounded brown shell, long tail and large head
Common snapping turtle
Chelydra serpentina

Side by side

FeatureAlligator snapping turtleCommon snapping turtle
SHELLThree tall ridges of spiked scutes, one down the center and one on each side; an extra row of scutes on each side; squarer outlineLower, smoother and more rounded, without tall ridges; saw-tooth edges at the sides and rear
HEADVery large, with a sharply hooked beak and fleshy bumps on the head and neckLarge, often marked with small black lines or spots; eyes visible from above
LUREA worm-like flap on the tongue used to lure fishNone
TAILLong and muscular, with smooth, rounded bumpsLong, with a sawtooth row of large pointed scales on top
SHELL LENGTHUsually 15–20 in (38–51 cm); occasionally over 30 inAbout 8–19 in (20–49 cm)
WEIGHTAbout 35–150 lb (16–68 kg); record over 250 lbTypically 10–35 lb (4.5–16 kg)
HABITATDeep water: big rivers, sloughs, oxbow lakes, reservoirsAlmost any permanent water: ponds, creeks, swamps, even golf-course ponds and brackish water
ON LANDRarely leaves the water except to nest; seldom basksOften crosses roads to nest or find new water
DIETMostly fish, plus turtles, snakes, crayfish, mussels, small mammals and nuts such as acornsOmnivore: invertebrates, fish, frogs, birds, small mammals and a lot of plant material
EGGSOne clutch a year of 9–61 eggs (about 28 on average)About 2–60 eggs per clutch
STATUSProtected in many states, including Missouri, Illinois and FloridaCommon and widespread

Both turtles have a small lower shell and a quick, powerful bite, and both will lunge when cornered on land. Neither is venomous, but give either one plenty of room.

Where you’ll find them

Alligator snapping turtle resting on a river bottom among submerged logs
Alligator snapper · deep rivers
Common snapping turtle walking across grass away from a pond
Common snapper · ponds & creeks

Alligator snapping turtles are southern river turtles. They live mainly in the Southeast, in river systems that drain to the Gulf of Mexico, and reach north up the Mississippi Valley into Missouri and southern Illinois. In Florida they are found only in the Panhandle and the Suwannee River basin. By day they hide among root snags and sunken logs in deep pools and come out to feed at night.

Common snapping turtles are far more widespread and turn up in almost any permanent water, from Nebraska and northern Illinois to nearly all of Florida. If you see a snapping turtle in a small pond, a roadside ditch or crossing a road, it is almost certainly a common snapper.

Three quick checks

Spiked ridges on an alligator snapping turtle's shellShell ridges
Three tall spiked ridges mean alligator snapper
Common snapping turtle's head seen from aboveEyes from above
If you can see the eyes from above, think common snapper
Common snapping turtle's tail with a sawtooth crestTail crest
A sawtooth crest on the tail means common snapper

Alligator snapping turtles are protected in much of their range. In Missouri, for example, it is illegal to capture, kill or collect one, and anglers who hook one must release it unharmed.

Nesting and lifespan

Both species spend nearly their whole lives in water, and only females come ashore to dig nests. Alligator snappers nest from late April through June and lay a single clutch a year; some females skip years. In Florida, common snappers nest from about April to June, starting as early as February in the south. In both, nest temperature decides whether hatchlings are male or female, and raccoons are major nest raiders.

Both are long-lived. Alligator snappers may take 11 to 13 years or more to mature and can live for 70 years or longer; common snappers can reach about 50 years.