Comparison · Two harmless striped snakes

Common garter snake vs western ribbon snake

Quick answer

Both are harmless, striped relatives in the genus Thamnophis. The western ribbon snake is pencil-thin with a very long tail, clean white lips and a bold pair of light spots on top of the head. The common garter snake is sturdier, with black bars on its lip scales, usually no head spots, and side stripes set lower on the body.

Common garter snake with a yellow back stripe and dark checkered sides, resting in grass
Common garter snake
Thamnophis sirtalis
Slender black western ribbon snake with an orange back stripe and pale side stripes, stretched along a stem near water
Western ribbon snake
Thamnophis proximus

Side by side

FeatureCommon garter snakeWestern ribbon snake
BUILDMedium buildVery slender, almost pencil-thin
TAILShorter in proportionLong: about one-third of the body length
SIDE STRIPEOn scale rows 2 and 3, counting up from the bellyHigher, on scale rows 3 and 4
BACK STRIPEWhite, yellow, gray or orangeUsually orange, sometimes yellowish
BODY COLORTan, brown or black, often with rows of dark spots; some show red between scales or a checkerboard lookBlack or dark gray overall
LIPSLip scales edged with black barsPlain white lips with no black edging
HEAD SPOTSUsually noneA pair of large light spots on top of the head, often partly joined
SIZEOften 15–40 in (38–100 cm); Louisiana gives up to 45 in (114 cm)Typically about 2 ft (61 cm); up to about 35 in (90 cm)
DIETMostly earthworms, plus frogs, toads, fish and other small animalsMostly frogs and small fish
YOUNGLive birth; litters can be large, roughly 9 to 80Live birth; about 10–15 young in Illinois
VENOMHarmlessHarmless

Color alone will fool you: both snakes can show an orange or yellow back stripe. The fastest checks are the lips (white and plain on the ribbon snake, black-barred on the garter snake) and how far the snake’s tail runs on past the vent.

Where you’ll find them

Common garter snake crossing short grass at a woodland edge
Garter snake · woods, edges & yards
Western ribbon snake draped over low plants at the edge of a marsh
Ribbon snake · marsh & pond edges

The common garter snake is a generalist. It lives in forests and forest edges, usually not far from water, and even turns up in vacant city lots. The western ribbon snake sticks much closer to water: plants along swamps, marshes, ponds, ditches and slow rivers, where it climbs into low bushes and swims readily. Where their ranges overlap, a striped snake right at the water’s edge or in shrubs over the water is more likely to be a ribbon snake.

State guides: Texas · Oklahoma

Also confused with

Plains garter snake with a bright back stripe and dark-checkered sidesPlains garter snake
Another striped Thamnophis of the central US
HARMLESS
Eastern ribbon snake, a slender striped snake, among wetland plantsEastern ribbon snake
Close relative; the light head spot is usually missing
HARMLESS

None of these striped snakes is venomous. Ribbon snakes often bite when handled, and a garter snake may flatten out and put on a defensive display, so the kindest choice is to watch and let either one go on its way.

Behavior and seasons

Common garter snakes are unusually cold-tolerant. They mate as soon as they leave their winter dens, as early as March in southern Illinois, and may even come out to bask on warm winter days. When cornered, a garter snake often flattens its head and spreads its body to show off its spot pattern.

Western ribbon snakes are quick and wary, and they climb and swim readily, so they tend to vanish into plants or water when disturbed. Both spend the winter underground, in rock crevices or burrows for the ribbon snake. Both species give birth to live young, mostly from midsummer into early fall.